Faux-Dupes: ELF Essential Bronzer in Luminance and theBalm Mary Lou-Manizer

I thought I found a dupe for theBalm Mary Lou-Manizer, but the products are actually very different when swatched/applied. On the left is theBalm Mary Lou-Manizer, a pigmented golden highlight, and on the right is the ELF Essential bronzer in Luminance, a subtle gold-based bronzer. They look eerily similar in the pan and even on the fingers, though, don't they?!